Horticultural Lighting Types: Not All Grow Lights Are Equal

Horticultural Lighting Types: Not All Grow Lights Are Equal

Horticultural lighting isn't all equal: two grow lights drawing the same wattage can deliver very different amounts of usable light to your plants. Choosing the right type, and checking the right numbers, is the difference between strong, compact growth and a stretched, underperforming crop.

This guide covers why cheap grow lights often cost more in the long run, the main types of horticultural lighting (LED, HID and fluorescent), how to choose a light, light cycles for each growth stage and common lighting problems.


💸 Why cheap grow lights cost you more

A grow light's job is to deliver photosynthetic light, not just brightness. Plants respond to photons in the 400–700 nanometre range, known as PAR (photosynthetically active radiation), so a light that looks bright to you isn't necessarily useful to your plants.

Budget lights often skip the figures that show real performance. Before you buy, look for:

  • PPF (photosynthetic photon flux) in µmol/s — the total usable light the fixture puts out
  • Efficacy in µmol/J — how much usable light you get per unit of power
  • A PPFD map — how much of that light lands on each part of your canopy
  • A warranty and a rated lifespan

If you're new to these terms, our tutorial on light output explains each one in plain English.

💡 A-Grade Tip: Compare grow lights by PPF and µmol/J, not watts or lumens. Lumens measure brightness as the human eye sees it, which is weighted towards green light, so they tell you little about plant growth.


💡 The main types of horticultural lighting

Grow lights fall into three main groups. LED is now the standard for most indoor growers, HID is the older high-output technology it has largely replaced, and fluorescent is mostly limited to small-scale propagation.

LED (light-emitting diode)

LED grow lights are now the go-to choice for most horticultural applications, and growers are steadily replacing HPS fixtures with them. In a 2025 survey of North American indoor cultivators, 78% used LED in the flowering stage, while HPS use in flower fell from 62% in 2016 to 23%.

The main reason is efficiency. To qualify for the DesignLights Consortium (DLC) horticultural list, an LED fixture must reach at least 2.3 µmol/J. By comparison, a double-ended 1000W HPS with an electronic ballast delivers around 1.7 µmol/J, and an older 400W single-ended HPS on a magnetic ballast around 0.9 µmol/J.

LEDs also hold their output for longer. DLC requirements call for fixtures to maintain their light output for at least 36,000 hours, which is roughly eight years at 12 hours a day. The trade-off is a higher upfront cost than an equivalent HID setup, which lower power use and no lamp replacements help offset over time.

Full spectrum LED

Full spectrum LEDs use mostly white diodes, often with added red, to produce a broad, sunlight-like spectrum. Early LED grow lights used narrow-band red and blue diodes only, which gave off a purple glow and made it hard to check plant health by eye. Most quality LED fixtures today are full spectrum.

HID (high-intensity discharge)

HID lamps produce light by passing an electrical arc through a gas-filled tube, and they need a ballast to run. They were the indoor-growing standard for decades, but they run hot and lose output as the lamp ages.

HPS (high-pressure sodium)

HPS lamps give off a warm yellow-orange light that's strong in the red and orange range, which is why they were traditionally used for flowering. They're still in use, but their share is falling quickly as growers switch to LED.

MH (metal halide)

MH lamps give off a cool blue-white light that was traditionally used for vegetative growth. They've dropped sharply in popularity: MH was the most common vegetative light in 2016, used by 43% of surveyed growers, but only 10% in 2025.

CMH (ceramic metal halide)

CMH lamps, also sold as LEC (light-emitting ceramic), use a ceramic arc tube to produce a broad spectrum that's closer to sunlight than HPS or MH. A quality 315W CMH lamp is rated at up to 1.9 µmol/J and holds around 90% of its output at 8,000 hours.

CMH was once tipped to replace HPS, but LED took that role instead. CMH is still sold and some growers value its spectrum, but its efficiency sits below the DLC minimum for LED fixtures, and it's now a niche choice rather than a growing one.

Fluorescent (T5 and CFL)

Fluorescent T5 battens and CFLs (compact fluorescent lamps) are low-output lights, best suited to seedlings and cuttings for their first few weeks. Low-wattage LED propagation lights are now a common alternative, doing the same job with less heat.

Light type Typical efficacy Status Notes
LED (DLC-qualified) 2.3 µmol/J or higher Current standard Highest efficiency, long life, higher upfront cost
CMH 315W Up to 1.9 µmol/J Niche Broad spectrum, needs a CMH-specific ballast
HPS double-ended 1000W Around 1.7 µmol/J Declining High heat, lamp replacement needed
HPS single-ended 400W (magnetic) Around 0.9 µmol/J Legacy Worth upgrading if you're still running one
MH Not listed Declining Largely replaced by full spectrum LED for veg
Fluorescent (T5, CFL) Not listed Propagation only Low output, suits seedlings and cuttings

🔍 How to choose a grow light for your setup

Match the light to your space and growth stage rather than buying the most powerful unit you can afford:

  • Size: check the PPFD map covers your tent footprint evenly
  • Efficiency: aim for 2.3 µmol/J or higher if you're buying LED
  • Heat: LEDs put less heat at the canopy than HID, which makes temperature easier to manage in a small tent

⏱️ Light cycles for each growth stage

For photoperiod plants, the number of hours of light and dark each day (the photoperiod) controls whether they keep growing or start flowering.

Growth stage Light cycle (on/off) Status Notes
Propagation 24/0 or 18/6 Seedlings and cuttings Low-intensity light only
Vegetative 18/6 Leaf and stem growth Plants stay in veg while nights are short
Flowering 12/12 Bud and fruit set A long, uninterrupted dark period triggers flowering

⚠️ Common grow light problems and fixes

Problem Likely cause Status Fix
Tall, stretched seedlings Light too weak or too far away Common Lower the light or increase intensity gradually
Pale or bleached top leaves Light too intense or too close Common Raise the light or dim it
Growth slowing over time under HID Ageing lamp losing output Common Replace HPS lamps at around 12,000 hours
Uneven growth across the canopy Light footprint too small or dirty reflector Occasional Check the PPFD map, add a light or clean reflectors

💡 A-Grade Tip: Clean your bulbs and reflectors every year or two. Dust and grime can cut light output by as much as 10–15%, and you're still paying for the power.


📝 Key takeaways for choosing horticultural lighting

Not all horticultural lighting is equal. LED is now the most efficient and widely used option, HID lights (HPS, MH and CMH) are in decline and fluorescent is best kept for propagation. Compare lights by PPF and µmol/J, and match the photoperiod to your plants' growth stage.

Read our guide to PPF, PPFD and DLI to size your light properly, or get in touch with the A-Grade team if you've got questions about your own setup.


📚 References

  1. Erik Runkle, Michigan State University, LED lighting: A 2024 update, 2024. https://www.canr.msu.edu/floriculture/uploads/files/2024-01,%20Update%20on%20LED%20efficacy.pdf
  2. Erik Runkle, Michigan State University, Advancements in lighting, 2023. https://www.canr.msu.edu/floriculture/uploads/files/Advancements%20in%20lighting.pdf
  3. Erik Runkle, Michigan State University, Fixture efficacy, 2020. https://www.canr.msu.edu/floriculture/uploads/files/20-01,%20Fixture%20efficacy.pdf
  4. Erik Runkle, Michigan State University, Lighting efficacy, 2017. https://www.canr.msu.edu/floriculture/uploads/files/lighting-efficacy.pdf
  5. Erik Runkle, Michigan State University, Maximize supplemental lighting, 2018. https://www.canr.msu.edu/floriculture/uploads/files/maximizesupplementallighting.pdf
  6. Cannabis Business Times, Fluence 2025 State of the Cannabis Lighting Market research results, 2025. https://www.cannabisbusinesstimes.com/home/article/15772068/fluence-2025-state-of-the-cannabis-lighting-market-research-results
  7. Philips Lighting, Green Power CDM-TP lamps technical data. https://images.philips.com/is/content/PhilipsConsumer/PDFDownloads/United%20States/ODLI20150514_001-UPD-en_US-p-6414.pdf

Categories

> Propagation
> Plant Nutrition & Health
> Pest & Disease
> Hydroponic Environment
> Harvest
> How To...
> Geek Out With A-Grade
> Water Control
> Plant Training
> Grow Medium
> Troubleshooting
> Hydroponic Basics

Other Tutorials

Horticultural Lighting Types: Not All Grow Lights Are Equal
Regular Lamps vs Grow Lights for Indoor Plants: What to Know
What Is a Good Hydroponics Starter Kit for Beginners?
The Best Hydroponic Kits for Beginners: What To Look For
Understanding Full-Spectrum LED Grow Lights And Yields

premium hydroponic store

We're committed to helping communities in Australia grow
Shop now

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.